| Date | Match | League | Result | OU 2.5 | Both to score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 8/22/26 | Sutton United vs Hartlepool United | Blue Square Premier | 2:1 | Yes | Yes |
| 2/8/25 | Sutton United vs Hartlepool United | Blue Square Premier | 1:2 | Yes | Yes |
| 10/5/24 | Hartlepool United vs Sutton United | Blue Square Premier | 4:3 | Yes | Yes |
| 2/11/23 | Hartlepool United vs Sutton United | League Two | 2:2 | Yes | Yes |
| 9/17/22 | Sutton United vs Hartlepool United | League Two | 2:0 | No | No |
| 2/19/22 | Hartlepool United vs Sutton United | League Two | 1:1 | No | Yes |
| 9/14/21 | Sutton United vs Hartlepool United | League Two | 1:0 | No | No |
| 5/23/21 | Sutton United vs Hartlepool United | Blue Square Premier | 3:0 | Yes | No |
| 1/30/21 | Hartlepool United vs Sutton United | Blue Square Premier | 1:0 | No | No |
| 3/14/20 | Sutton United vs Hartlepool United | Blue Square Premier | 1:1 | No | Yes |
| 8/3/19 | Hartlepool United vs Sutton United | Blue Square Premier | 1:3 | Yes | Yes |
| 3/2/19 | Sutton United vs Hartlepool United | Blue Square Premier | 2:2 | Yes | Yes |
| 10/27/18 | Hartlepool United vs Sutton United | Blue Square Premier | 2:3 | Yes | Yes |
| 4/14/18 | Sutton United vs Hartlepool United | Blue Square Premier | 1:1 | No | Yes |
| 10/21/17 | Hartlepool United vs Sutton United | Blue Square Premier | 1:1 | No | Yes |